7 Challenge Match Success Stories: Effective Promotions

/in , , /by

Challenge match campaigns are a powerful fundraising tool for nonprofits looking to drive donor engagement and boost donations. By offering to match contributions, organizations create a sense of urgency and excitement among supporters. These campaigns motivate donors by showing them that their gift will have an even greater impact.

In this post, we’ll highlight seven nonprofits that ran successful challenge match campaigns:

  1. Healthy Birthday
  2. UOAA
  3. Fresno Chaffee Zoo
  4. Union Gospel Mission
  5. Sofia’s Hope
  6. Humane Animal Rescue of Pittsburgh
  7. UWC-USA

By sharing these organizations’ top strategies, promotions, and results, we hope to inspire your next challenge match campaign and provide you with actionable insights to increase engagement and funding for your cause.

Healthy Birthday

Nonprofit website: https://healthybirthday.org/

Healthy Birthday, a nonprofit focused on supporting children’s health and wellness, capitalized on Giving Tuesday by launching a $10,000 matching grant appeal. To maximize engagement, they added a series of incentives for donors. These included a free spa gift certificate for those who gave a specific amount, as well as a branded t-shirt for donors who raised a certain amount through peer-to-peer fundraising.

The combination of a matching gift, a clear goal, and intriguing incentives proved to be a highly effective promotional strategy. Here’s what made Healthy Birthday’s campaign stand out:

  • Engaging incentives: The addition of spa gift certificates and t-shirts incentivized higher donation amounts and encouraged peer-to-peer fundraising.
  • Use of Giving Tuesday: Tying the campaign to Giving Tuesday helped leverage the global giving momentum, which is vital for short-term fundraising success.
  • Social media push: They promoted the campaign across multiple social media platforms, increasing visibility and encouraging wider participation.

For your own campaign, adding value through fun incentives can significantly boost both engagement and total funds raised.

Healthy Birthday is an example of a challenge match success story.

UOAA

Nonprofit website: https://www.ostomy.org/

In the Fall of 2023, the United Ostomy Associations of America (UOAA) launched a Matching Donor Program that aimed to raise $50,000. With a generous anonymous donor matching all gifts, UOAA exceeded their goal by $10,000, bringing in a total of $60,000.

UOAA’s campaign benefited from several key promotional tactics:

  • Clear and consistent messaging: They communicated the matching opportunity clearly through email and social media posts, ensuring donors knew exactly how their contributions would be doubled.
  • Strategic donor relationships: The nonprofit built a relationship with a matching donor who was deeply invested in the cause, making it easier to secure a significant donation.
  • Tight timeline: The campaign was time-limited, creating a sense of urgency that encouraged immediate action from donors.

For nonprofits looking to replicate this success, consider securing a major donor or corporate partner to provide a match. Make sure the match is clearly communicated and the timeline is well-promoted.

Fresno Chaffee Zoo

Nonprofit website: http://fcz.org/

Fresno Chaffee Zoo launched the Elephant Baby Matching Gift Program, aimed at supporting two African elephants expected to give birth in 2024. The program needed to raise between $75,000 and $100,000 to kick-start matching donations, with every dollar donated being matched to double the impact.

To promote the campaign, the Zoo utilized a mix of methods:

  • Kickoff event: They began the campaign on World Elephant Day with social media posts, QR codes, and visitor handouts at the zoo.
  • In-person events: A special ‘baby shower’ event was held to generate excitement, featuring community partners like the Fresno Economic Opportunities Commission.
  • QR codes and easy donation access: QR codes throughout the zoo and event materials made it easy for donors to quickly contribute while on-site.

This multifaceted promotional strategy combined events, online engagement, and clear, impactful visuals to successfully generate support for the elephant babies.

Fresno Chaffee Zoo is an example of a challenge match success story.

Union Gospel Mission

Nonprofit website: https://ugmportland.org/

Union Gospel Mission in Portland launched a matching campaign with a $50,000 gift from a group of generous donors. The mission emphasized how each dollar donated would have twice the impact, helping to feed and shelter twice as many people.

This campaign was especially effective due to:

  • Compelling, donor-focused messaging: The organization clearly communicated the life-changing impact of donations, making it easy for donors to see the direct effect of their contributions.
  • Seasonal urgency: The timing of the campaign, in the run-up to summer when donations typically slow down, helped encourage donors to act immediately.
  • Personalized outreach: Their appeal, including personal testimonials, created a deeper connection with the mission and its supporters.

Nonprofits can replicate this by highlighting the difference that donations make in people’s lives and emphasizing the urgency of giving during slower months.

UGM is an example of a challenge match success story.

Sofia’s Hope

Nonprofit website: https://www.sofiashope.org/

Sofia’s Hope, a nonprofit focused on childhood cancer, ran multiple successful matching campaigns, including one during their Summer and End of Year appeals. They secured corporate sponsors to match all donations up to $5K in the summer and $10K for the end-of-year campaign.

They also held a Round Up Campaign at a local restaurant in September for Childhood Cancer Awareness Month, where all funds raised were matched by the restaurant.

What made Sofia’s Hope successful:

  • Corporate partnerships: They leveraged corporate matching gifts to significantly increase donations, with the added bonus of matching from local businesses.
  • Community involvement: The Round Up Campaign created a community-driven fundraising effort that engaged both local businesses and the public.
  • Multiple fundraising channels: They marketed the campaign through social media, text messaging, and e-blasts, ensuring a wide reach.

For nonprofits looking to replicate this success, focusing on local partnerships and corporate matches can enhance your fundraising efforts.

Humane Animal Rescue of Pittsburgh

Nonprofit website; https://humaneanimalrescue.org/

Humane Animal Rescue of Pittsburgh (HARP) used matching gifts to boost recurring donations in June. Donors who committed to becoming monthly supporters through the HARP 365 program had their first two monthly gifts doubled by Fetch Pet Insurance.

This campaign was effective because:

  • Emphasis on recurring gifts: Focusing on long-term support rather than one-time donations helped build a steady stream of income.
  • Corporate partnership: Fetch Pet Insurance was a natural partner for HARP, aligning with their mission and creating a strong donor engagement opportunity.
  • Clear, ongoing impact: By highlighting the value of recurring donations, HARP was able to convert one-time donors into long-term supporters.

For your organization, building corporate partnerships for monthly giving matches is a great way to ensure sustained funding.

UWC-USA

Nonprofit website: https://www.uwc-usa.org/

UWC-USA leveraged corporate matching gifts in their campaigns, particularly during events like Giving Tuesday. By reaching out to alumni and supporters who worked at companies with matching gift programs, they were able to increase donations by around 30%.

Key strategies included:

  • Targeted outreach: They identified potential donors who worked for companies with matching gift programs and sent them tailored emails to encourage participation.
  • Promoting corporate matches: Once supporters were on the donation page, they were encouraged to check their eligibility for corporate matching gifts, increasing the chances of participation.
  • Leveraging Giving Tuesday: By linking the campaign to a popular giving day, UWC-USA maximized visibility and donor engagement.

To replicate this strategy, use donor data to identify matching gift opportunities and promote them through targeted emails or text messages.

Wrapping Up & Next Steps

Challenge match campaigns are a proven way to increase donations and engage supporters in a meaningful way. By looking at the success stories of nonprofits like these, you can gain insights into how to run your own effective matching campaigns.

Use the strategies discussed here to inspire your next effort, and remember: with the right messaging, strategic partnerships, and powerful promotions, your challenge match can have an incredible impact on your fundraising goals.

Raise Even More with Employee Matching Gifts!

In addition to challenge grants, employee matching gifts offer another excellent opportunity for raising funds. With Double the Donation, your nonprofit can easily identify matching gift opportunities and track progress to maximize the impact of these funds. Start raising more today by integrating employee matching gifts into your campaigns! Request a demo today to get started.